After the introduction of a regulation on garbage separation, the separation of waste in Hamburg should be self-evident, but Hamburg does not live up to its own claims. According to Sven Kummereincke, editor at
„Die Welt", many residents do not do the garbage separation as it is prescribed. The Tenants' Association, the Housing and Environmental Associations, want more pressure on residents by introducing coercive measures such as fines for refuseniks. However, the authority is voluntary.
The law on enforcement is in place, but it is not implemented. This is: Private households are obliged since 2015 to separate garbage according to the Kreislaufwirtschaftsgesetz (KrWG). So that a wrong separation is punishable.
According to Sven Kummereincke, Hamburg could not achieve the desired recycling targets. The obligation for all homeowners, which has existed since 1 January 2011, to erect containers for biowaste and paper in addition to the residual waste bin, is still ignored by many. There are currently 110,214 biotons in the city and 893,000 households on 232,000 properties. This corresponds to a rate of 47,7 percent. So far, not even every second of fulfils its mandatory. The paper has a better rate: 141,141 containers equal 60,6 percent.
The environmental agency says that there are also successes. The residual waste quantity had fallen by 30,000 tonnes more than planned. Hamburg separates its garbage much better than a few years ago.
According to "Zeit Online", the wrong sorting of garbage is another big problem in Hamburg. Many people in Hamburg do not sort the waste properly because they have difficulty sorting waste. Which ton is the right one for which garbage? This question is asked many citizens in Hamburg. About half of the waste in the yellow bin does not belong there, as the Federal Association of Secondary Raw Materials and Disposal (BVSE) announced.
Big problems get the recovery companies, for example, if a diaper ends up in the packaging waste. This is then considered contaminated and may no longer be recycled.
The Association of Municipal Enterprises (VKU) suspects that it is partly due to the lack of education about the separation system in some social milieus. According to a VKU spokesman, increasing migration could also be a reason for a lack of willingness to isolate: the German system is difficult for foreign nationals to understand and needs to be better explained.
In addition, more and more citizens show according to the "Hamburger Abendblatt" the illegal disposal of waste in the city cleaning. In 2017, the number of reported litterings reached a new high. 25,813 times the people from Hamburg complained about illegal waste disposal. In 2016 there were 22,520 and in 2015 only 19,633 complaints. Thus, the number of complaints has risen by 31 percent within two years. Only about four percent of the perpetrators were punished. The districts with the most illegal waste deposits are still St. Georg and St. Pauli. Although the city has tightened the fines and next year increases the responsibility for the city cleaning, the amount of illegally disposed waste in Hamburg has grown further.